Challenger App

No.1 PSC Learning App

1M+ Downloads

Consider the constitutional and conventional aspects of the Attorney General's office.

  1. The principle that the Attorney General holds office during the 'pleasure of the President' is a constitutional provision found in Article 76.

  2. The practice of the Attorney General resigning when the government changes is a well-established constitutional law.

  3. The Attorney General's right to participate in parliamentary committees without voting rights is derived from Article 88 of the Constitution.

Which of the statement(s) given above is/are correct?

A1 and 2 only

B2 and 3 only

C1 and 3 only

D1, 2 and 3

Answer:

C. 1 and 3 only

Read Explanation:

Attorney General of India: Constitutional and Conventional Aspects

  • Constitutional Provision (Article 76): The Attorney General (AG) is the highest law officer in India. Article 76 of the Constitution states that the AG shall hold office during the pleasure of the President. This implies that the President can remove the AG at any time, though this power is exercised based on the advice of the government.

  • Tenure and Resignation: While the AG holds office during the President's pleasure, a strong convention has developed. It is customary for the Attorney General to resign upon the resignation or removal of the government that appointed them. This convention upholds the principle of accountability and alignment with the executive.

  • Right to Participate in Parliament (Article 88): Article 88 of the Constitution grants the Attorney General the right to speak and to take part in the proceedings of both Houses of Parliament (Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha), and in any committee of Parliament of which he may be named a member. However, the AG does not have the right to vote in these proceedings. This right allows the government to receive legal advice directly within parliamentary deliberations.

  • Distinction between Constitutional Provision and Convention: It is crucial to differentiate between the explicit constitutional provisions and the established conventions. Statement 1 refers to the constitutional provision. Statement 2 describes a convention that has become an integral part of the constitutional understanding, even though not explicitly written as a mandatory act of resignation in the text. Statement 3 refers to another constitutional right explicitly granted by Article 88.

  • Exam Relevance: Questions often test the understanding of the AG's appointment, removal, rights, and the interplay between constitutional articles and established practices. Awareness of specific articles like 76 and 88, and the convention regarding resignation with the government, is key for competitive exams.


Related Questions:

With reference to the State Services, consider the following statements:

  1. The officers of State Services are selected by the respective State Public Service Commissions.

  2. The Chief Secretary heads the civil service administration in each state.

  3. State Services are classified into Group A, Group B, Group C, and Group D, similar to Central Services.

  4. The All India Services Act, 1951 mandates that at least 50% of senior posts in All India Services be filled by promotion from State Services.

Which of the statements given above are correct?

The recommendations submitted by the State Finance Commission to the Governor include principles governing:

  1. The sharing of net income of state-levied taxes between the Government and Panchayats.

  2. The appointment of executive officers for the Panchayats.

  3. The taxes, duties, cesses, and fees which may be marked for and expended by the Panchayats.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Consider the following statements about the classification of State Services:

  1. State Services are classified into Class-I to Class-IV, with Class-I and Class-II being gazetted.

  2. The Chief Secretary of the State heads the civil service administration in each State.

  3. Officers for State Services are appointed by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC).
    Which of the statement(s) given above is/are correct?

Which of the following statements are correct regarding the application of the Doctrine of Pleasure?

  1. The doctrine applies to members of the All India Services.

  2. The President can dismiss Supreme Court Judges under the Doctrine of Pleasure.

  3. Article 311 safeguards apply only to permanent civil servants.

What is Public Interest Litigation (PIL)?